From USA Today:
Helen Gurley Brown vs. Nellie Gray
Two women whose worldviews couldn't have been more divergent died just days apart, each leaving a dramatically different imprint on American society. Both sought to protect women's rights but were on opposite sides of a cultural battle that has shaped the past half-century. In the Civil War, the two sides were symbolized by "The Blue" and "The Gray." The sides in today's "civil war" could be symbolized by "The Brown" and "The Gray."
Helen Gurley Brown, writer of Sex and The Single Girl and for 32 years the editor of Cosmopolitan magazine, was in the vanguard of a movement that insisted women would only achieve equality through "reproductive rights." What that meant was that women should be free to sleep with whomever they desired with the inevitable consequence of aborting unplanned children conceived along the way.
Nellie Gray, a lawyer who walked away from a successful career to found the March for Life,
had a starkly different view of women's rights. To Gray, human rights
could not be broken down to their component parts. Everyone enjoyed the
same right to life bestowed by the creator and guaranteed by the
Constitution. Abortion both broke her heart and steeled her resolve.
The difference between "The Brown" and "The
Gray," was not, however, what many would say it was, namely, that "The
Brown" stands for the women and "The Gray" stands for the babies. The
real difference is that "The Brown" thinks you can separate the two and
"The Gray" says you can't. Both claimed they were serving women.
Brown, and the movement she represented, believed that women are served
by more access to "services" such as abortion, which frees them from
the burden of carrying and raising a child.
Gray, and the movement she represented, believed that you can stand both
for women and for the children in their wombs, and that their destinies
are intertwined: Loving and serving either means loving and serving
both.
Ironically, the same four words became a rallying
cry for both women. The same simple words are spoken from opposite ends
of the universe, with meanings directly contrary to each other.
"This
is my body" describes the pro-choice, pro-abortion rights mentality in
the most succinct way possible. I own this body and all its potential. I
decide whether the child occupying space in my womb lives or dies. I
answer to no one but myself.
"This is My Body"
meant something entirely different to Gray, and to everyone involved
in the anti-abortion work and advocacy. Those were the sacrificial
words spoken by Jesus Christ.
But
you don't have to be Christian to understand Jesus' message about love
and selflessness. Christ teaches the meaning of love: I sacrifice myself
for the good of the other person. Abortion teaches the opposite of
love: I sacrifice the other person for the good of myself. Christ gives
his body away so others might live; abortion-rights supporters cling to
their own bodies so others might die.
Abortion
divides Americans more profoundly than any other issue. Some say it is
intractable. But maybe the reason is that we're looking at it only as a
battle to be won or lost on the political front. This is a deeper
spiritual battle, perhaps embodied best by the very women who gave their
lives to these respective causes.
Father Frank Pavone is the national director of Priests for Life.
No comments:
Post a Comment